Haji Ali Dargah to allow entry of women

10/25/2016

NEW DELHI, Oct. 25: In a victory for equal right to worship for women, the Haji Ali Dargah Trust (India) on Monday conceded before the Supreme Court of India that it has resolved to allow women to enter the sanctum sanctorum of the famed dargah in Mumbai “at par with men”.

In a hearing before a Bench led by Chief Justice of India T.S. Thakur, the Trust said it has come around and passed a resolution on October 11, 2016 to comply with a Bombay High Court judgment to give women equal access like men.

“Is that not what Your Lordships wanted? Is this not progressive?” senior advocate Gopal Subramanium, representing the Trust, asked the Bench.

Disposing off the challenge raised by the Trust against the High Court decision, the Supreme Court allowed the Trust two weeks' time to remove certain structural obstructions inside the dargah to give women unrestricted view of the sanctum sanctorum. The Bench directed that any "default or neglect" in compliance by the Trust can be raised before the High Court.

The hearing however saw the court nudge the Trust on why it had separate entrances for men and women into the dargah.

“There may be women who do not want separate entrances. Why do you have to distinguish between man and woman here?” Chief Justice Thakur queried.

The court set the tone for the hearing when it conveyed to Mr. Subramanium its disinclination to hear expostulations based on doctrines and academic texts about the customs of the dargah. Chief Justice Thakur said the court only wanted to know from Mr. Subramanium whether “women would be given access to the sanctum like men or not”.

In the previous hearing, the Supreme Court had taken a serious view of the religious “exclusion and restrictions” women suffer. It had pointed to Kerala's Sabarimala temple and the Haji Ali dargah to note that 'exclusion' was practised by both Hindus and Muslims and the "problem needs to be addressed''.

"Exclusion is not there if nobody is allowed after a certain point. There is exclusion if women are not allowed after a certain point and men are," Chief Justice Thakur had defined the term.

The Bombay High Court had on August 26 held that the ban imposed by the Dargah Trust, prohibiting women from entering the sanctum sanctorum of the Haji Ali Dargah, contravened Articles 14, 15 and 25 of the Constitution and said women should be permitted to enter the sanctum sanctorum like men.

The High Court had ruled this on a PIL plea filed by two women from the NGO Bharatiya Muslim Mahila Andolan. It had held that the Trust had no power to alter or modify the mode or manner of religious practices of any individual or any group. (TH)

 

In the previous hearing, the Supreme Court had taken a serious view of the religious “exclusion and restrictions” women suffer. It had pointed to Kerala's Sabarimala temple and the Haji Ali dargah to note that 'exclusion' was practised by both Hindus and Muslims and the "problem needs to be addressed''.

"Exclusion is not there if nobody is allowed after a certain point. There is exclusion if women are not allowed after a certain point and men are," Chief Justice Thakur had defined the term.

The Bombay High Court had on August 26 held that the ban imposed by the Dargah Trust, prohibiting women from entering the sanctum sanctorum of the Haji Ali Dargah, contravened Articles 14, 15 and 25 of the Constitution and said women should be permitted to enter the sanctum sanctorum like men.

 

The High Court had ruled this on a PIL plea filed by two women from the NGO Bharatiya Muslim Mahila Andolan. It had held that the Trust had no power to alter or modify the mode or manner of religious practices of any individual or any group. (TH)

Related News

Bakar-Eid today

Kathmandu, Sept. 13: The Muslims community across the country are observing the Bakar-Eid with much fanfare Tuesday. The Muslims people visit the mosques, offer prayers to Allah, observed Namaj and exchange greetings to each others in the festival.  The festival falls on the 70th day of the Ramadan, the nine…

Policeman held on charge of raping mentally ill woman

   Dhangadi, Sept 24:  Police have arrested a policeman for allegedly raping a mentally challenged woman at Campus Chowk in Dhangadi district.   According to the District Police Office (DPO) , Dhangadi, Gaursingh Faral, allegedly raped the woman taking her to a nearby bush on Friday.   The locals caught…

Energy crisis major setback for urban development

Kathmandu, Sept. 30:Experts have raised concerns about inadequate infrastructures and amenities in sprawling urban areas. Speaking at a talk programme on ‘Urban challenges and the role of private sector in Nepal’, they said that the new urban areas should be developed in a planned manner and should be equipped with…

Animal sacrifice can never be religion

Pokhara, Oct 3: Speakers at a programme held on the occasion of the International Day of Non- Violence expressed a joint commitment to discourage animal sacrifices in temples and religious shrines in name of religion. During the interaction on minimizing the scale of animal sacrifices held by Woman for Social…

Less complaints filed at help desks: Police

Kathmandu, Oct. 5: Citizens’ Help Desks (CHDs) that were established ahead of the festive seasons are receiving less public complaints than what the police had expected. The Nepal Police in the wake of the festive mood of Dashain, Tihar and Chhath had set up nine CHDs at major junctions of…

At least 50 hurt in Tanahu bus accident

Damauli, Oct 6: A least 50 people were injured when a passenger bus met with an accident at Amreni of Byas Municipality-1, Tahanu today.  A bus (Ga 1 Kha 4153) en route to Damauli from Muglin veered off the road and fell into a paddy field. Overtaking was suspected as…

Video

Find Us on Facebook

From Social

Tokyo (Japan), Sept. 13: A new leadership assumed responsibilities at the Non Resident Nepalese Association (NRNA), Japan on Sunday. The new office bearers took oath of office and secrecy after a long fought battle resulting from dissatisfaction from those who…

Lama led officials assume responsibility in NRNA Japan